In plain words
A home-built NAS is an ordinary computer (an old PC, a mini PC, a second-hand server) on which you install a specialised system instead of Windows. You get the same thing as an off-the-shelf NAS, often with more powerful and more upgradeable hardware, but it's up to you to assemble, configure and maintain it. The three most common systems each have their own philosophy: TrueNAS bets everything on data safety with ZFS, OpenMediaVault on lightness and simplicity, Unraid on flexibility with disks of any size.
To compare with a ready-made NAS, see the comparison of off-the-shelf NAS devices. For RAID and ZFS concepts, see understanding storage.
1. The three systems at a glance
| TrueNAS Community Edition | OpenMediaVault | Unraid | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Vendor | iXsystems (United States) | Community project (Volker Theile) | Lime Technology (United States) |
| Base | Debian (Linux) | Debian (Linux); OMV 8 "Synchrony" is based on Debian 13 | Slackware (Linux) |
| Licence | Open source and free | Open source and free | Proprietary, paid: perpetual licence (Starter up to 6 storage devices, Unleashed and Lifetime with no limit; one year of updates for Starter and Unleashed, lifetime for Lifetime), tied to the USB stick or, since Unraid 7.3, to the motherboard through the TPM |
| Storage | ZFS only | mdadm (software RAID) + ext4, XFS, Btrfs; ZFS, SnapRAID and mergerfs through extensions | Parity array (independent disks) and ZFS or Btrfs pools |
| Philosophy | Data integrity above all | Light, close to Debian, even runs on a Raspberry Pi | Mix disks of any size, add one disk at a time |
| Interface | Complete, storage-oriented | Simple and plain | Very approachable, large library of community applications |
TrueNAS: a single edition today
TrueNAS SCALE (on Linux) has been renamed TrueNAS Community Edition. The old TrueNAS CORE edition, on FreeBSD, is no longer developed: for a new installation, choose the Community Edition. In 2026 iXsystems moves to one major version a year, numbered by year (TrueNAS 26).
2. The detailed comparison
| Criterion | TrueNAS | OpenMediaVault | Unraid |
|---|---|---|---|
| Disks of different sizes | Not recommended: within a group (vdev), capacity is aligned on the smallest disk | Possible with mergerfs + SnapRAID, otherwise aligned on the smallest (mdadm) | Yes, it's its strong point; the parity disk must be at least as large as the largest data disk |
| Adding a disk | Possible one at a time in a RAIDZ since OpenZFS 2.3 (RAIDZ expansion), or by adding a whole vdev | Yes (growing an mdadm array) | Yes, one disk at a time: the new disk is cleared first, with no parity recalculation |
| Data integrity | Excellent: checksums and self-healing on every block | Depends on the file system chosen (Btrfs or ZFS for checksums) | Good on ZFS pools; on the array, checksums through an extension |
| Performance | High: reads and writes spread across all the disks | High with mdadm RAID | On the array, reads at the speed of a single disk; slower writes because of parity (often 20 to 40 MB/s, more in turbo write mode); an SSD cache pool absorbs writes |
| Power consumption | All the disks spin together | All the disks spin together (except with mergerfs) | Low: only the disks in use spin, the others stop |
| Loss beyond the tolerance | The whole pool is lost | The whole array is lost (mdadm) | Only the failed disks are lost: the others remain readable individually |
| Containers | Apps (Docker), built-in catalogue, and custom applications in Compose | Docker and Compose through the omv-extras extension | Docker, huge community catalogue (Community Applications) |
| Virtual machines | Yes (KVM), and LXC containers announced with TrueNAS 26 | Possible through an extension (KVM), rarely used | Yes (KVM), with easy graphics card passthrough |
| Updates | Annual version and intermediate releases | Follows Debian; updates through apt | Regular; one year of updates included (Starter, Unleashed, extendable), lifetime with Lifetime |
| Learning curve | Medium: ZFS requires understanding pools, vdevs and datasets | Low for anyone used to Debian | Low: the most approachable |
3. Recommended hardware
| TrueNAS | OpenMediaVault | Unraid | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Processor | 64-bit x86, 2 cores minimum; more for apps and VMs | 64-bit x86 or 64-bit ARM (Raspberry Pi 4 and 5) | 64-bit x86 |
| Memory | 8 GB minimum, 16 GB or more recommended (ZFS uses free memory as a cache) | 1 to 2 GB is enough for files; more for Docker | 4 GB recommended as a minimum, 8 GB or more with Docker and VMs |
| ECC | Recommended | Optional | Optional |
| Boot | A small dedicated SSD (16 GB minimum), not a USB stick | An SSD or a good-quality microSD card (Raspberry Pi) | A good-quality USB stick, or since Unraid 7.3 an internal SSD or NVMe drive, optionally mirrored |
| Disk controller | Motherboard SATA ports or an HBA card in IT mode; never hardware RAID | SATA ports or HBA | SATA ports or HBA; no hardware RAID |
No hardware RAID under ZFS
ZFS must see each disk individually. A RAID card, even set to "JBOD", hides errors and the disks' SMART status. If you need more ports, get an HBA card (for example based on an LSI SAS2008, SAS2308 or SAS3008 controller) flashed to IT mode, widely available second-hand.
Example configurations
| Use | Typical hardware | Recommended system |
|---|---|---|
| Small, very frugal NAS for files and backups | Raspberry Pi 5 with a SATA enclosure, or an old laptop with USB drives | OpenMediaVault |
| Family NAS: photos, Jellyfin, a few containers | Intel N100 or N150 mini PC with a 4-bay enclosure, 16 GB | Unraid or OpenMediaVault |
| Large media library with disks of various sizes, collected over time | Tower with 6 to 10 bays, Intel processor with Quick Sync | Unraid |
| Precious data, business backups, replication | Server with ECC memory, HBA card, identical disks | TrueNAS |
4. The other options
| Option | Principle | For whom |
|---|---|---|
| Proxmox VE + TrueNAS in a VM | The hypervisor hosts TrueNAS in a VM, which is given the whole HBA card through passthrough | A homelab that wants a single server for everything; for confident users only (see installing Proxmox VE) |
| Proxmox VE alone | ZFS is built into Proxmox: an LXC container with Samba shares the files | Those who already run Proxmox and have a simple sharing need |
| Debian or Ubuntu + Samba | A regular distribution, shares configured by hand | Linux administrators who want to control everything |
| XigmaNAS | Successor to NAS4Free, on FreeBSD, with ZFS | FreeBSD regulars |
The disks of a TrueNAS VM
Never give a TrueNAS VM virtual disks created on another storage, nor disks passed through one by one without care: ZFS would lose direct access to the disks. The reliable method is passing through the whole controller card (HBA), which requires a processor and a motherboard compatible with IOMMU (VT-d or AMD-Vi).
5. Which one to choose?
| Your priority | Recommended choice |
|---|---|
| Data safety above all, identical disks | TrueNAS |
| Modest hardware or a Raspberry Pi, a system close to Debian | OpenMediaVault |
| Disks of different sizes, adding disks over time, low power consumption | Unraid |
| A simple interface with lots of ready-to-install applications | Unraid, then TrueNAS |
| Staying 100% open source and free | TrueNAS or OpenMediaVault |
| A single server for VMs and storage | Proxmox VE, with or without TrueNAS in a VM |
6. Common rules
- The NAS is not a backup of itself: copy important data elsewhere, including an off-site copy (see the 3-2-1 rule).
- NAS-range CMR disks; for ZFS, disks of the same size within a vdev.
- Enable scheduled SMART tests, a monthly scrub with ZFS or Btrfs, and email alerts.
- Schedule regular snapshots of the shares.
- Don't expose the admin interface to the internet: go through a VPN (WireGuard, Tailscale).
- Create a named administrator account (
spo) and disable or protect the defaultrootoradminaccount. - Write down your configuration (disks, serial numbers, pools, shares): on the day of a failure, you'll be glad you did.
Key points
- TrueNAS: ZFS, maximum integrity, ideal with identical disks and 16 GB of memory.
- OpenMediaVault: light and simple, based on Debian, even runs on a Raspberry Pi.
- Unraid: disks of any size, added one by one, low power consumption, very approachable, but paid.
- Never hardware RAID under ZFS: an HBA card in IT mode to add ports.
- Whatever the system: back up elsewhere, SMART, scrub, snapshots, no direct exposure to the internet.
Sources
- TrueNAS documentation
- TrueNAS: TrueNAS 26 announcement
- OpenMediaVault: release of OMV 8 "Synchrony"
- OpenMediaVault documentation
- Unraid documentation
- Unraid: Unraid 7.3 release, booting from an internal drive and TPM licensing (May 2026)
- Unraid: licence offers
- Unraid: the array and its parity disks
- OpenZFS documentation