In plain words
An off-the-shelf NAS is a small specialised computer, supplied with its own system and interface: you slide in disks, follow the wizard, and within an hour you have a file, photo and backup server for the whole household or office. The brands all sell roughly the same hardware; what really sets them apart is the software: how simple it is, its applications, its security and how long it will keep being updated.
For the basics (RAID, Btrfs, ZFS, SMB…), see understanding storage. To build your own NAS with TrueNAS, OpenMediaVault or Unraid, see TrueNAS, OpenMediaVault or Unraid.
1. The five brands at a glance
| Synology | QNAP | UGREEN | Asustor | TerraMaster | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Origin | Taiwan | Taiwan | China | Taiwan (subsidiary of the ASUS group) | China |
| System | DSM | QTS (ext4) or QuTS hero (ZFS) | UGOS Pro | ADM | TOS |
| Strength | The most polished software, very complete applications | Powerful, highly expandable hardware, ZFS | Modern hardware, recent and well-designed interface | Good balance of hardware and software, all-NVMe models | Capable hardware, system you're free to replace |
| Weakness | Hardware often behind (processor, network) | Cluttered interface, history of exploited vulnerabilities | System still young, smaller application ecosystem | Smaller community and documentation | System less mature than DSM |
| Typical audience | Home users and small businesses who want it to "just work" | Advanced users, small businesses, creatives | Demanding home users, homelab | Home users, creatives | Tinkerers, homelab |
2. The detailed comparison
| Criterion | Synology | QNAP | UGREEN | Asustor | TerraMaster |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| File systems | Btrfs, ext4 | ext4 (QTS), ZFS (QuTS hero) | Btrfs, ext4 | Btrfs, ext4 | Btrfs, ext4 |
| RAID | SHR, SHR-2, classic RAID | Classic RAID, RAIDZ (QuTS hero) | Classic RAID | Classic RAID | Classic RAID, TRAID (SHR equivalent) |
| Snapshots | Yes, with an immutable option | Yes | Yes | Yes (Btrfs) | Yes (Btrfs) |
| Containers | Container Manager (Docker) | Container Station (Docker, LXD) | Built-in Docker | Portainer and Docker (App Central) | Docker |
| Virtual machines | Virtual Machine Manager | Virtualization Station | Yes (on x86 models) | VirtualBox or VMs (depending on model) | Yes (depending on model) |
| Photos | Synology Photos, face recognition | QuMagie | Photo album with built-in AI | Photo Gallery | Photos |
| Synchronisation | Synology Drive (Dropbox-style), very polished | Qsync | Built-in synchronisation | EZ Sync | TerraSync |
| Computer and server backup | Active Backup for Business: PCs, servers, VMs, Microsoft 365, with no extra licence | Hybrid Backup Sync, Hyper Data Protector | PC and phone backup | Backup Plan, DataSync | Centralized Backup, Duple Backup |
| Typical network | 1 to 2.5 Gbit/s, 10 Gbit/s on some models | 2.5 Gbit/s common, 10 Gbit/s frequent | 2.5 to 10 Gbit/s | 2.5 Gbit/s common, 10 Gbit/s on some models | 2.5 Gbit/s common, 10 Gbit/s on some models |
| NVMe slots | Cache, and storage on some models | Cache and storage | Storage and cache | Cache and storage, all-NVMe models (Flashstor) | Cache and storage |
| Another system installable | Not supported | Not supported | Possible: the manufacturer doesn't lock booting | Not supported | Possible, often used with Unraid or TrueNAS |
The exact features vary by model and system version: check the datasheet of the model you're considering.
Synology and third-party drives: what you need to know
In 2025, Synology restricted the Plus-range NAS models released that year to its own drives or certified drives. Faced with criticism, the brand backtracked with DSM 7.3 (October 2025), which once again accepts hard drives from other manufacturers on those models. Before buying, check the model's compatibility list and make sure your drives don't trigger a warning, especially for NVMe SSDs used as storage.
3. How to choose your model
The number of bays
| Bays | Possible RAID | For whom |
|---|---|---|
| 2 | RAID 1 (mirror) | Home user: photos, documents, PC backups |
| 4 | RAID 5, RAID 6, RAID 10, SHR-2 | Family, homelab, small business; the best compromise |
| 5 to 8 | RAID 6, SHR-2, RAIDZ2 | Large volumes, video, small businesses |
| Rack (1U, 2U) | All | Business, network rack |
Take one more bay than you need today: adding a disk to an existing array is easy, changing NAS much less so.
The processor
| Type | Examples | Consequences |
|---|---|---|
| ARM (Realtek, Annapurna) | Entry-level models | Enough for sharing files and backing up; Docker limited or absent, no VMs |
| Low-power x86 | Intel Celeron, N100, N150, N305 | Docker, Plex or Jellyfin with hardware transcoding (Intel Quick Sync), small VMs |
| High-performance x86 | AMD Ryzen Embedded, Intel Core | Several VMs, many containers, 10 Gbit/s at full speed |
To watch your films remotely with Jellyfin or Plex, an Intel processor with integrated graphics (Quick Sync) is the most efficient: it converts video on the fly effortlessly. Some AMD Ryzen Embedded processors lack integrated graphics.
Memory, network, NVMe
- Memory: 4 GB is enough for file use; aim for 8 to 16 GB for Docker and VMs, and 16 GB or more with ZFS. Check that it's expandable (a free slot) and, for professional use, whether ECC is offered.
- Network: a 2.5 Gbit/s port nearly doubles speeds compared with Gigabit, provided the switch and the PC keep up. 10 Gbit/s only helps if your computers and network have it too.
- NVMe: a cache speeds up random access (VMs, databases, many small files) but not copies of large files. A separate NVMe volume for Docker and VMs is often more useful than a cache.
The rest
- Support lifetime: a NAS lasts 5 to 10 years. Check how long the brand keeps updating its older models; Synology and QNAP publish their end-of-support schedules.
- Noise and power: a NAS runs day and night. Expect 15 to 50 W depending on the model and the number of disks; 7,200 rpm disks are noisier than 5,400 rpm ones.
- Disks: choose NAS-range CMR disks (see understanding storage).
4. Which one for whom?
| Your situation | Recommended choice | Why |
|---|---|---|
| I want a simple, reliable NAS for the family | Synology, 2 or 4 bays | DSM is the simplest and most complete; Synology Photos and Drive replace consumer clouds |
| Small business: shared files and computer backup | Synology with Active Backup for Business | Centralised backup of PCs, servers and Microsoft 365 with no extra licence |
| I want ZFS without building my own server | QNAP with QuTS hero | ZFS with a complete graphical interface |
| Powerful hardware, Docker, 10 Gbit/s | QNAP, UGREEN or Asustor | More recent processors and faster networking |
| I want to be able to install TrueNAS or Unraid later | UGREEN or TerraMaster | Booting isn't locked, the hardware is standard |
| Video editing, large files, silence | Asustor Flashstor or all-NVMe models | Very fast, silent, compact |
5. Security: set it up on day one
NAS devices are a prime target: they hold all the data and are often exposed to the internet so they can be reached from outside. No brand is spared: the Qlocker (2021) and DeadBolt (2022) ransomware encrypted thousands of QNAP and Asustor NAS devices, and Synology NAS devices regularly face password-guessing campaigns.
Don't expose the admin interface to the internet
Disable UPnP on the NAS and on the internet router, forward no port to the admin interface, and avoid "easy connect" services if you don't need them. To reach the NAS from outside, go through a VPN: WireGuard on your router, or Tailscale, which most NAS devices offer as an application.
| Setting | Why |
|---|---|
Disable the default admin account and create a named administrator (for example spo) |
The name admin is the first one attackers try |
| Two-factor authentication on administrator accounts | A stolen password is no longer enough |
| Automatic updates of the system (at least the security fixes) and applications | Most attacks exploit vulnerabilities that have already been fixed |
| Automatic IP blocking after several failures | Slows down password guessing |
| Scheduled snapshots, immutable if the NAS allows it | Go back to the state before ransomware or a mistake |
| Uninstall unused applications | Fewer services, fewer vulnerabilities |
| Backup outside the NAS (unplugged USB drive, another NAS, encrypted cloud) | The NAS is not a backup of itself: see the 3-2-1 rule |
| Email alerts (disks, failed backups) | React before the failure |
Key points
- The software makes the difference: Synology for simplicity and applications, QNAP for power and ZFS, UGREEN, Asustor and TerraMaster for modern hardware.
- 4 bays is the best compromise; take one more bay than you need.
- x86 processor (ideally Intel with Quick Sync) for Docker, Jellyfin or Plex; 8 GB of memory minimum in that case.
- 2.5 Gbit/s for transfers clearly faster than Gigabit.
- Never expose administration to the internet: VPN, two-factor authentication, updates, snapshots, and a backup outside the NAS.